Quantcast

How the Baby Veronica case could play out - abc27 WHTM

How the Baby Veronica case could play out

Posted: Updated:

By Stefanie Bainum
sbainum@abcnews4.com

Charleston, S.C. (WCIV) – All eyes will be on Washington, DC as the Baby Veronica case nears the end of its court battle. Tuesday marks the day the Supreme Court will hear oral arguments from both sides of the case.

The legal fight centers around a little girl named Veronica. She was adopted by Matt and Melanie Capobianco of James Island shortly after she was born.

But her birth father, a member of the Cherokee Nation, regained custody in 2011 under the Indian Child Welfare-- a law meant to protect Native American tribe culture by keeping American Indian children with their American Indian parents.

Former South Carolina Attorney General Charlie Condon says the strict legal question before the justices will be whether or not the biological father in this case is a "parent" in the meaning of the Indian Child Welfare Act.

There are reports that the biological father, Dusten Brown, did not provide emotional or financial support to Veronica's mother during the pregnancy.

The Justices will want to make clear what a parent means under the act and whether federal law should take precedent over state law.

"If you look at South Carolina state law they have some winning arguments that the baby should stay here," Condon said. "It's a very interesting mix of factual, legal questions and interplay between the federal and state government that involves this really emotional subject of where the child should stay."

The Indian Child Welfare Act has only been taken up by the Supreme Court twice since it was enacted in 1978.

"The fact that the Supreme Court took jurisdiction in this case is a positive development because otherwise they would have been out of luck and the baby would have remained with the father," Former South Carolina Attorney General Charlie Condon says. "So it's very positive that the Supreme Court is hearing this."

"It's a challenging case though because that statue gives very strong presence for that child remaining with the father so I do believe that they do have a challenge ahead of them to win this case."

A definitive ruling on the case by the Supreme Court should come down in June.


  • Stefanie Bainum

    Email: sbainum@abcnews4.com Reporter Profile




  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • Endless Shrimp® Returns to Red Lobster®

    Endless Shrimp® Returns to Red Lobster®

    Starting Monday, September 1st, Red Lobster's Endless Shrimp, the number one guest-requested promotion, is back for a limited time. This year, guests can satisfy their shrimp cravings through one of the most...More >>
    Starting Monday, September 1st, Red Lobster's Endless Shrimp, the number one guest-requested promotion, is back for a limited time. This year, guests can satisfy their shrimp cravings through one of the most...More >>
  • Garden Spot marching band performs with Fall Out Boy

    Garden Spot marching band performs with Fall Out Boy

    Monday, September 1 2014 5:33 PM EDT2014-09-01 21:33:13 GMT
    When we last left off, the Garden Spot Marching Band was waiting to see if the band Fall Out Boy would live up to their word. Back in July, the school board told the marching band they could not perform one of Fall Out Boy's songs because of the language in the lyrics.More >>
    When we last left off, the Garden Spot Marching Band was waiting to see if the band Fall Out Boy would live up to their word. Back in July, the school board told the marching band they could not perform one of Fall Out Boy's songs because of the language in the lyrics.
    More >>
  • Boy dies after lightning strike near Peach Bottom

    Boy dies after lightning strike near Peach Bottom

    Monday, September 1 2014 12:03 PM EDT2014-09-01 16:03:23 GMT
    A lightning strike has killed a boy who was swimming in a Lancaster County creek.More >>
    A lightning strike has killed a boy who was swimming in a Lancaster County creek.
    More >>
Powered by WorldNow