Quantcast

Capitol fight over organ donation bill - abc27 WHTM

Capitol fight over organ donation bill

Posted: Updated:
HARRISBURG, Pa. (WHTM) -

A battle over bodies is about to hit the Capitol over bills that would update Pennsylvania's organ donation law.

Former Pennsylvania State Policeman Bruce Edwards is an aggressive advocate.

"I was basically legally blind in my right eye," Edwards said about his vision prior to a 1988 corneal transplant.

He would like to see any law that facilitates the easier harvesting of organs and tissue. He joined a recent rally at the Capitol pushing for Senate Bill 850 and House Bill 30. The prime sponsor is Representative Bryan Cutler—(R) Lancaster County—whose prime motivation is the 8,400 Pennsylvanians awaiting organs.

"Young people an adults are waiting and dying while they wait," Cutler said at the rally. On average, one person a day in Pennsylvania dies before an organ is secured.

But Edwards didn't just receive.

In 2008, 20 years after getting transplanted sight, he gave in a way no parent ever wants to.

His 17-year-old daughter Melissa was killed in a car accident. He allowed her tissues to be harvested. They helped six people.

He knows a parent's anguish and knows how tough it is to ask a grieving loved one to give up organs and tissues.

"Any extra pain that you experience that day, a thousand times over comes back in comfort over the years," Edwards said while fighting back tears. "Knowing that something good and positive came out of something horrible."

Pennsylvania's organ donation law dates to 1994, in the days following the highly publicized heart and liver double transplant of Governor Bob Casey. It was a national leader then but other states now do more to facilitate organ donation. Supporters call SB 850 and HB 30 a modernization of current law. Critics, like state coroners, some law enforcement and victim's advocates, call it a bad idea.

"Once you decide to give any part of your body, they can take everything," said Susan Shanaman, a lobbyist who represents coroners in Pennsylvania.

Shanaman says the bills would let organ harvesters usurp a coroner's power and potentially interfere with crime scene evidence that could allow killers to go free.

"What happens to the evidence?" Shanaman asks. "They're not forensically trained and once that evidence is gone the evidence is gone."

Dauphin County District Attorney agrees there are potential problems and says he's working with the bills sponsors to tighten up language.

But Edwards, a former State Police investigator, insists he would not support any legislation that would harm a crime scene, Besides, he says, 45 states have already passed laws similar to what he's pushing for Pennsylvania.

"So you're saying the other 45 state's that have done it already they made a mistake," Edwards said. "But nothing bad's happening in those states."

  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • Ex-girlfriend of homicide suspect reported missing

    Ex-girlfriend of homicide suspect reported missing

    Saturday, July 26 2014 7:42 PM EDT2014-07-26 23:42:05 GMT
     York City police are asking for the public's help in locating a missing woman they believe may be with the suspect in a homicide from last weekend.More >>
     York City police are asking for the public's help in locating a missing woman they believe may be with the suspect in a homicide from last weekend.More >>
  • Carlisle police search for retail theft suspect

    Carlisle police search for retail theft suspect

    Sunday, July 27 2014 12:53 PM EDT2014-07-27 16:53:44 GMT
    Police in Carlisle are searching for a retail theft suspect seen in this surveillance photo.According to police, the male in the photo was allegedly involved in a retail theft at the Giant Food Store in Carlisle.Anyone with information is asked to contact Carlisle Police at 717-243-5252.More >>
    Police in Carlisle are searching for a retail theft suspect seen in this surveillance photo.According to police, the male in the photo was allegedly involved in a retail theft at the Giant Food Store in Carlisle.Anyone with information is asked to contact Carlisle Police at 717-243-5252.More >>
  • Severe T'Storm Watch Tonight

    Severe T'Storm Watch Tonight

    Sunday, July 27 2014 10:45 PM EDT2014-07-28 02:45:07 GMT
    Lower humidity levels return MondayMore >>
    Lower humidity levels return Monday
    More >>
Powered by WorldNow